Is Selling Magic Cards Worth It?

Is selling Magic cards worth it? Some cards are worth quite a bit and if you sell them yourself, you can keep the profits. Regardless of the way you do it, by selling the cards yourself, more money is collect than by selling your collection to your local game store.

What is the best way to sell bulk Magic cards?

  • Craigslist. One of the places I've had the most luck selling bulk is Craigslist.
  • Instant Collections. Like bulk lots of commons and uncommons, another strategy for selling true bulk on Craigslist involves making it into instant collections.
  • Plan B.
  • Plan C.
  • End Step.
  • Where can I get rid of Magic cards?


  • Ebay - Single lot auction, fastest way to get rid of them and make a few bucks.
  • Donate to some younger players.
  • Find a store online or regular store that buys lots or rares like
  • How do I know if my Magic cards are worth money?

    To tell if a card is rare or mythic rare we look at the expansion set symbol. Almost all cards will have an expansion set symbol on it to help you identify it. The colour of this symbol will tell you what rarity the card is; common = black, uncommon = silver, rare = gold, mythic = orange-red / bronze.

    How much is the average Magic The Gathering card worth?

    The answer is yes! Basically, every single Magic card has a cash value, even though for most common cards they only value around $0.05-$0.10.

    Related advices for Is Selling Magic Cards Worth It?

    Do MTG cards increase in value?

    Each of these non-Reserved List cards has more than doubled in price over the last year. MTG sets like Double Masters and Eternal Masters create opportunities for players to pick up reprinted cards at discounted prices. However, cards players and collectors want tend to rise back up in price.

    How much is bulk MTG worth?

    Most retailers will buy bulk rares for ten cents apiece, and most will buy bulk commons and uncommons for between $2 and $3 per 1,000. That is basically the cheapest that Magic cards can be acquired in bulk, since they can always be sold and bought at that bulk price.

    What can you do with unwanted Magic cards?

    Bring them to your comic store and get a couple dollars. This way when you really need that uncommon you know you opened you just go to the store and buy it for a few cents or a dollar at most. I save my extras in a box until it's full, then I donate it to my LGS. They have a lot of kids and kids love free stuff.

    How do you get rid of bulk cards MTG?

  • remove a play set of anything you want to keep / sees play so you can have them available in future.
  • go through and list them all on puca trade and/or deck box -> trade away as many as possible and get cards you really want.
  • Bundle them in groups of 1,000 and sell them to a LGS for ~$3-5 / 1,000.

  • How many Black Lotus cards are there?

    Based on the total number of cards released in the Alpha, Beta and Unlimited sets, it seems that roughly 22,800 Black Lotus cards were printed.

    What is considered bulk rare MTG?

    Anything less than $. 25 is a bulk rare.

    Are MTG bulk lots worth it?

    Very worth it, as to accumulate card otherwise will often cost you twice as much, over a longer period of time. I've bought a few bulk rare lots and known people who bought many more. It's not worth it unless you just want lots of cards.

    How many cards are in a pound of magic?

    Simple math and knowing that there are 454 grams in a pound results in one pound of magic cards containing about 257 cards.

    How profitable is Magic the Gathering?

    WotC's Q2 2021 revenue rose to $406 million, up 118% from $187 million in Q2 2020. The Magic: The Gathering and Dungeons & Dragons publisher's profit also grew at an impressive rate to $193 million from $74 million.

    Do you sleeve Commons?

    When it comes to sleeving common baseball cards, you should sleeve anything believed to have potential value. This could mean sleeving all true rookie cards in case a player shoots to stardom, or, sleeving all cards that fit your collector criteria.

    What should I do in bulk?

    What is a Buylist?

    A buylist is a list of cards you own that you want to sell to us. The buylist prices listed are what we will pay you for that card in near-mint condition (see the table below for played condition prices).

    Are foil Magic cards worth more?

    It's at the point where (especially for the rares and mythic rares) the foil versions of the cards are worth barely more than the non-foil versions.

    Was this post helpful?

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published.